The Canon Is Not a Canon

  • Post author:
  • Post published:
  • Post category:Uncategorized

The lists keep arriving, and they keep disagreeing, and the disagreement is the point. Kinda Funny’s recent top 100 placed The Last of Us at number one, followed by Portal 2 slot gacor and two Zelda games, with Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, a game released in 2025, landing at number seven . The aggregate of over 900 lists compiled by a Reddit user put Super Mario World at the top, with A Link to the Past and Resident Evil 4 close behind . Famitsu’s PlayStation poll crowned Final Fantasy VII, with Monster Hunter Portable 2nd G and Xenogears rounding out the top three . Metacritic’s historical data still has Ocarina of Time at a 99, with SoulCalibur and Grand Theft Auto IV at 98 . These are not variations on a theme. They are different themes entirely, and the fact that they all claim to identify the “best” games suggests that the word is doing less work than we think.

The PlayStation canon, if it exists, is a recent invention. The Famitsu poll that crowned Final Fantasy VII was conducted for the platform’s 30th anniversary, and it drew on roughly 4,000 voters, most of whom were Japanese . That is a tiny sample, and it skews heavily toward a particular demographic and a particular moment in the platform’s history. Sixteen of the thirty games on that list were PS1 titles, and neither the PS5 nor the Vita appeared at all . This is not a canon; it is a memory. The people who voted grew up with the PS1, and their sense of what PlayStation means is bound up with the games they played when they were young. A poll of American players in their twenties would produce a very different list, and a poll of Japanese players in their forties would produce another one still.

The PSP’s absence from these conversations is telling. Only two PSP games made Famitsu’s top thirty, both from the Monster Hunter series . Western lists rarely give the platform more than a footnote. Yet the PSP produced games that were formally inventive in ways that home console games could not afford to be, and the people who played them remember them with a specificity that is rare in discussions of “best games.” Patapon’s marching song, LocoRoco’s tilting world, the ad hoc multiplayer sessions of Dissidia—these are memories that belong to a device and a moment, and they do not translate into the language of aggregate scores and ranked lists . The PSP’s canon is a private one, held by the people who were there, and it may be more durable for that.

The broader lesson is that the “best games” conversation is not really about games at all. It is about the conditions under which a game becomes part of someone’s life, and those conditions are irreducibly particular. A game that scores a 97 and is forgotten in a year has less claim to greatness than a game that scored an 80 and is still being discussed two decades later. The lists and polls and aggregates are attempts to formalize something that resists formalization: the moment when a game stops being a product and becomes a memory. The best games are the ones that survive that transition, whatever their Metacritic score, and the only honest list is the one that acknowledges its own contingency. The canon is not a canon. It is a conversation, and it is one worth having, as long as we remember that no one is ever going to win it.